While there is a vast literature on Christianity and science, the approach taken in Church Scientific is best presented by only a handful of books. That makes recommendations much simpler…
1. Start here!
Here are the books we recommend starting with.
- Alan Chalmers: What is this thing called Science? (1978; 4th edn 2013): The best introduction we know to the problem of what scientific progress really is. Although not written from a Christian perspective, this book sets the agenda for much of what we discuss in Church Scientific.
- Lesslie Newbigin: The Other Side of 1984 (1983): short but contains very accessible introductions to worldview, the Enlightenment and the thought of Michael Polanyi. Newbiggin urges a “missionary” engagement with post-Enlightenment culture in place of the privatization of Christian faith that he saw in Britain 35 years ago.
- Craig Bartholomew and Mike Goheen: Christian Philosophy: A Systematic and Narrative Introduction (2013): A broad overview of the sweep of the Western tradition of philosophy, from ancient Greek to modern thought. The final chapters focus on Christian traditions of Reformed Epistemology and Reformational Philosophy, providing a gateway to what Church Scientific looks at.
- Keith C Sewell: Problems in the “Christian” origins of modern science (Pro Rege 30(4):15-17, 2002): A short article laying out a few points that are distinctive of our approach. How can we relate God’s gracious general revelation to the reality of sin?
- Roy A Clouser: The Myth of Religious Neutrality (2nd edn 2005): The standard textbook on a Reformational philosophy of religion and science. Clear and friendly!
- Willem Ouweneel: Wisdom for Thinkers: an introduction to Christian philosophy (2014): A short introduction to Reformational philosophy with plenty of general comments about scientific thinking.
2. More advanced reading: Christian writers
- Herman Dooyeweerd: The Secularization of Science (1966): One of the most helpful short articles on the nature of science by the cofounder of Reformational philosophy. [pdf here]
- Lydia Jaeger: What the Heavens Declare: Science in the light of creation (2012): A sustained elaboration of the philosophical understanding of God’s freedom in creation and how this illuminates the practice of the sciences and the defence of Christian faith.
- Michael Polanyi: Personal Knowledge (1958):
- Michael Polanyi: The Tacit Dimension (1966): Polanyi’s lectures in which he introduces the notion of tacit knowledge and other illuminating features of the human condition that undergird scientific investigation.
- Marinus D Stafleu: Theories at Work: On the structure and functioning of theories in science, in particular during the Copernican Revolution (1987): A compelling philosophical account of the systematics of scientific progress, backed up by careful historical investigation of developments in the 17th and 18th centuries.
3. More advanced reading: non-Christian perspectives
Just a few of the most helpful books written from non-Christian perspectives.
- Thomas S Kuhn: The Structure of Scientific Revolutions (1962…2012): the classic picture of scientific progress being mediated by the social structures in which it takes place. Compelling – and ultimately a little unsettlling!
- Paul K Feyerabend: Against Method: Outline of an anarchistic theory of knowledge (1970, 1975, etc): one of the more iconoclastic contributions to philosophy of science, replete with examples that challenge conventional wisdom. [pdfs here: 3 parts + notes]
- Steven Shapin: The Scientific Revolution (1996): a very readable introduction to the 17th-century people, places and activities to which the roots of much modern science can be traced. For those of us trained in the sciences, this is a gloriously fresh take on history of science – treating it as sociology and thereby challenging us to empathise with thinkers whose scientific knowledge was very different.
- as well as What is This Thing Called Science? mentioned under (1) above.
4. Advanced scholarly works
Read these if you want the serious scholarship which has influenced some of the above works!
- Herman Dooyeweerd: New Critique of Theoretical Thought (4 vols: 1969): Dooyeweerd’s magnum opus, with extensive references to Kant and subsequent philosophers in the German idealistic and phenomenological traditions. Not for the faint-hearted, but worth perusing to see how the author combines Christian zeal with erudite scholarship.
- Jeremy GA Ive: The Roots of Reformational Philosophy: a beautiful scholarly unification of the views of the two cofounders of Reformational philosophy: Herman Dooyeweerd and Dirk Vollenhoven, in the context of trinitarian theology. As yet it is unpublished but rumoured to be on its way; for now, seek access through Jeremy’s page on All Of Life Redeemed.
- Daniel FM Strauss: Philosophy: Discipline of the Disciplines (2009): A masterly treatment of Reformational philosophy by probably the world’s foremost expert. If you’ve immersed yourself sufficiently to have deep questions, this tome can probably answer them.
- Marinus D Stafleu: Time And Again: A Systematic Analysis of the Foundations of Physics (1980)